1976: Rich Keeley
1977: Don Franco
1978: Frank Burr
1979: Don Franco
1980: Pat Pavelski
1981: Lou Desiderio
1982,83,84: Rich Borchers
1985: Tom Desmond
1986: Walter Peterson
1987: Jim Lawler
1988: Robert Howell
1989: Ron Yates
1990: Rich Borchers
1991: Larry Coluccio
1992,93: Tim Desmond
1994: Robert Howell
1995: Rich Borchers
1996: Kenn Quinn
1997: John Painter
1998: Tim Desmond
1999: Bob Capelli
2000,01,02,03: John Painter (02,03 seasons undefeated)
2004: Bob Macchi
2005,06: Steve Payne
2007: John Painter (undefeated)
2008: Tim Desmond
2009: John Painter
2010: Charlie Zervas
2011: Jim Lynch
2012: John Painter
2013: Joe Castelano
2014,15: Steve Payne
2016: Bob Howell