Cain, Butch (Plymouth Flames)
Cain, Zac (Plymouth Flames)
Calawerts, Billy (Brookfield Bulldogs)
*Calhoun, Kyle (North Prairie Dawgs)
Callahan, Brady (Howards Grove Riverdogs)
Calmes, Dave (North Lake Lakers)
Calmes, Jake (North Lake Lakers)
Calmes, Sam (North Lake Lakers)
*Calvert, Jason (Muskego Impact)
*Calvert, Justin (Muskego Impact)
*Campbell, Scott (Delavan Blackhawks)
Capasson, Jon (Burlington Barons)
*Capasso, Sam (Racine Kiwanis)
Carberry, Scott (Sussex Cardinals)
*Carey, Michael (Merton Amvets)
*Carmody, John (Genoa City Red Dogs)
Carpenter, Ben (North Shore Knights)
Carrington, Jimmy (Racine Kiwanis)
*Carriveau, Ben (Dousman Frogs)
*Cartledge, D.J. (Brookfield Bulldogs)
*Cartwright, Michael (Merton Amvets)
*Casey, David (Brookfield Blue Sox)
*Casey, Josh (Racine Erickson)
*Casper, Austin (East Troy Express)
Castro, Ernest (Brookfield Bulldogs)
*Catarazelli, Ryan (Dousman Frogs)
*Cedarholm, Jay (Menomonee Falls Lakers)
*Chadwick, Jeff (Menomonee Falls Lakers)
*Challe, Dan (Burlington Barons)
Chapman, Kurtis (Hartland Oilers)
*Chapman, Tony (Waterford Rivermen)
*Chardukian, Jordan (Kenosha Merchants)
*Charter, Adam (Monches Irish)
*Cheairs, Damian (Grafton Express)
Cheaney, Nicholas (Racine Kiwans)
*Cherry, Kyle (Merton Amvets)
*Childs, Martin (North Shore Knights)
*Childs, Milton (North Shore Knights)
*Childs, Myles (North Shore Knights)
Cho, Trevor (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Christensen, Austin (Waterford Rivermen)
Christensen, Tyler (Oconomowoc Titans)
Christenson, Devin (Plymouth Flames)
Christenson, Travis (Plymouth Flames)
*Christman, Matt (Menomonee Falls Lakers)
*Cikel, Aaron (Racine Kiwanis)
*Cirillo, Nate (Wales Royals)
Clark, Jordan (Grafton Express)
Clarke, Justin (Butler Bombers)
*Clemmons, Cory (Mukwonago Lakers)
*Cline, Chris (Saukville Saints)
*Clouthier, Chris (North Shore Knights)
*Cloutier, Jon Paul (Racine Kiwanis)
*Coenen, Kyle (Franklin Snappers)
Cohen, Tim (Oconomoowc Titans)
*Cokey, Aaron (Racine Kiwanis)
*Coleman, Chris (Dousman Frogs)
Collello, Vince (Brookfield Blue Sox)
*Collins, Brad (North Shore Knights)
Collins, Mike (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
Collins, Nick (Oconomowoc Five-Os)
*Collopy, Dr. Mike (Brookfield Blue Sox)
*Comerford, Clay (Plymouth Flames)
*Comerford, Cody (Plymouth Flames)
*Coon, Chris (North Shore Knights)
*Corallini, Chris (North Lake Lakers)
*Cordell, Brad (Thiensville-Mequon Twins)
*Connell, Sean (Dousman Frogs)
*Connelly, Cory (Monches Irish)
*Cook, Phil (Racine Kiwanis)
Cook, Richie (Wales/Waukesha Royals)
*Cornell, Chris (North Lake Lakers)
*Costa, Joe (North Prairie Dawgs)
Cottrell, Eric (Hartland Oilers)
Covarrubias, Adam (Ixonia Snappers)
Coyle, Mike (Saukville Saints)
*Crawley, Nolan (New Berlin Lakers)
*Croak, Brian (Monches Irish)
*Croak, Dan (Muskego Impact)
*Crossman, Evan (North Shore Knights)
*Cruz, Marcos Pena Lozo (Kenosha Merchants)
Cullen, Eric (Saukville Saints)
Cutshall, Eric (Rome Raiders)