2015

Evan Appleby

University of Pittsburg Johnstown

Devin Bell

Frostburg State University

Michael Castillo

Union College

Joe Gagliardi

University of Pittsburg Johnstown

Garrett Getz

Kutztown University

Nate Harmon

Southeastern University

Ronnie Healy

Union College

Kai Hess

McDaniel College

Chris Mattison

Southeastern University

Adam Reed

Virginia Commonwealth University

Andrew Shreiner

Mount Aloysius College

Brett Strahin

West Virginia State University

 2014

Chris Moylan

George Washington University

Brian Wirth

Limestone College

Logan Johnson

Southwest Baptist University

Ben Eppley

Kutztown University

John Capwell

Mansfield University

Matt Kurelja

Mansfield University

Chris Colletti

Shepherd University

Brain Laurito

Clarion University

Logan Funk

Shippensburg University

Collin Mills

Limestone College

Cody Harman

Limestone College

Jessie McAllister

Lock Haven University

Ryan Miller

Francis Marion University

Casey Clauss

Francis Marion University

2013

Brody Tennant

Wilmington University

Sam Crater

Shepherd University

Justin Goodrich

Shepherd University

Josh Swirchak

Wilmington University

Ryan Douglas

Wilmington University

Austin Hale

Shepherd University

Zach Sacoman

Mansfield University

Tom DenBleyker

University of Philadelphia

John Rickards

Kevin Kopas

Shepherd University

Stevenson University

2012

Chris Godfrey

Coppin State University

Joey Miller

Concord University

Max Miller

Mansfield University

Connor Graber

Mt. St. Mary's University

Quinn Taylor

Mansfield University

Matt DeWitt

James Madison University

Cal Hogan

Shippensburg University

Joey Zuniga

Mansfield University

Greg Dayhoff

Mansfield University

Garrett Nesbitt

Lehigh University

Brandon Costa

Concord University

Tyler Itnyre

University of Charleston

Chris Baker

Concord University

John Dockins

Kutztown University

2011

Jordan Hoke

Mount Union College

Tyler Basso

Shippensburg University

Tim Leather

Belhaven University

Mike Hnatuck

Mansfield University

Jamie Blackwell

Bluefield College

Joe Murphy

West Chester University

Tyler Shover

West Virginia University

Brett Moreland

Flagler College

Tim McCormick

Florida Southern College

Keith Picconi

Coastal Carolina University

Dan Dierdorff

West Virginia University

2010

Nick Meekins

Belhaven University

Thomas Moxley

Bridgewater College

Jordan Arnold

Salem International University

Alex Buccilli

Coastal Carolina University

Mike Mitchell

University of Maryland Baltimore County

David Ness

William Penn University

Josh McCauley

West Virginia University

Matt Siggins

University of Maryland Baltimore County

Jacob Mays

Concord University

Jon Patino

Belhaven University

Brock McCallister

Francis Marion University

Brian Paulhus

Francis Marion University

2009

Beau Smith

Mount Union College

Kyle Dietrich

Mars Hill College

Ryan Kassab

Long Island University

Matt Howard

Slippery Rock University

Nick Caito

Slippery Rock University

Ryan Starnowsky

Shippensburg University

Ben Scott

Elon University

Jimmy Gilford

Belhaven College

Mike Walters

Lynchburg College

Jake Hockensmith

University of Virgina - Wise

Evan Angle

Penn State Mont Alto

Frank Zier

Campbell University

Brad Wimmer

Radford University

2008

Dusty Haigler

University of Virgina - Wise

Bill Thompson

University of Virgina - Wise

Matt Hamilton

Mansfield University

Daniel Chevalier

Mansfield University

Brian Collins

Shepherd University

Rusty Smith

Mars Hill College

Tyler Winch

Towson State University

Shane Mills

University of Virgina - Wise

Tim Kellinger

Tusculum College

2007

Chris Nehl

University of Delaware

Jared Olson

University of Delaware

Irvin Sleighter

Mansfield University

Chad Smith

Mansfield University

John Marlette

Shenandoah University

Nate Mathis

Shenandoah University

Garrett Smith

Armstrong Atlantic State University

John Keravich

George Mason University

A.J. Mason

Alderson-Broaddus College

Gary Wolfe

Frostburg University

John Ortiz

Ohio Valley University

Josh Simons

Shenandoah University

Bryson Appel

Towson State University

2006

Travis Hubbard

Towson State University

Sam Schmitt

Ohio Valley

Nick Harner

Chowan College

William Bussey

Fairmont State University

Tim Kellinger

West Virginia University

Dustin Kolb

West Virginia Wesleyan

Cody Stinger

Mansfield University

Justin Doyle

Radford University

2005

Rick Lawyer

University of North Carolina-Pembrooke

Dan Leatherman

West Virginia University

Andy Taylor

Fairmont State University

Matt Rankin

University of South Carolina-Upstate

Sammy Hart

University of South Carolina-Upstate

Donald Rohrbaugh

Fairmont State University

Ethan Rager

Fairmont State University

Keith Kellinger

West Virginia Tech

Jonas Brinks

West Virginia Wesleyan

Matt Reynolds

Salisbury State University

2004

Brandon Conway

Montreal Expos 9th Round

Brandon Eshenour

Millersville University

Sam Mack

Penn State University

Gabe Ralston

Lebanon Valley College

Adam Sikorski

Indiana University of Pennsylvania

Phil Stone

George Mason University

Rhett Teller

St. Leo University

Wayne Toms

Ohio Valley College

2003

Bill Auch

Coppin State College

Keith Fritz

Shenandoah University

P.J. Hinson

Shenandoah University

Brian McClaughlin

Susquehanna University

Bryan Pittman

Radford University

Tony Showalter

Shepherd University