OHC All-Time Playoff Record In:
Regional Quarterfinals: 34-21 (.618 Winning %)
Regional Semifinals: 14-20 (.412 Winning %)
Regional Finals: 4-10 (.286 Winning %)
State Semifinals: 0-4 (.000 Winning %)
State Finals: N/A

OHC All-Time Overall Playoff Record: 52-55 (.486 Winning %)


OHC Playoff Results by Year:

OHC 2001 OHSAA Playoffs:
Southeastern 2-1 (Anna W 53-26, Covington W 27-21, Marion Local L 6-47)
Cedarville 1-1 (Bethel W 35-7, Marion Local L 0-38)

OHC 2002 OHSAA Playoffs:
Mechanicsburg 1-1 (Southeastern W 25-7, Marion Local L 0-42)
Northeastern 0-1 (Coldwater L 12-54)
Southeastern 0-1 (Mechanicsburg L 7-25) 

OHC 2003 OHSAA Playoffs:
Northeastern 0-1 (Reading L 13-42)
Triad 1-1 (Troy Christian W 48-12, Hardin Northern L 6-31)
Catholic Central 1-1 (Riverside W 26-0, Marion Local L 6-42)
Mechanicsburg 0-1 (Hardin Northern L 7-33)

OHC 2004 OHSAA Playoffs:
West Liberty-Salem 1-1 (Bishop Fenwick W 19-13, East Clinton L 10-21) 
Mechanicsburg 1-1 (Mississinawa Valley W 37-6, New Bremen L 25-34)
Catholic Central 1-1 (Riverside W 21-0, Hardin Northern L 13-27)

OHC 2005 OHSAA Playoffs:
Mechanicsburg 0-1 (Marion Local L 7-17)
Catholic Central 1-1 (Waynesfield-Goshen 36-13, Hardin Northern L 28-49)

OHC 2006 OHSAA Playoffs:
Mechanicsburg 2-1 (Triad W 61-0, Hardin Northern W 34-0, Marion Local L 0-14)
Catholic Central 1-1 (Lehman Catholic W 24-21, Marion Local L 20-49)
West Liberty-Salem 0-1 (Lima Central Catholic L 0-21)
Triad 0-1 (Mechanicsburg L 0-61)

OHC 2007 OHSAA Playoffs:
Catholic Central 3-1 (Waynesfield-Goshen W 28-6, Mechanicsburg W 24-17, Lehman Catholic W 48-14, Newark Catholic L 14-21)
West Liberty-Salem 1-1 (Waynesville W 45-21, West Jefferson L 24-56)
Mechanicsburg 1-1 (Sciotoville Community School W 48-21, Catholic Central L 17-24)

OHC 2008 OHSAA Playoffs:
Mechanicsburg 2-1 (Hamilton New Miami W 42-0, Covington W 40-14, Lehman Catholic L 13-28)
West Liberty-Salem 0-1 (Waynesville L 9-34)
Catholic Central 1-1 (Sciotoville Community School W 28-19, Lehman Catholic L 6-42)

OHC 2009 OHSAA Playoffs:
West Liberty-Salem 1-1 (West Jefferson W 3-0, St. Henry L 14-42)
Southeastern 1-1 (Waynesfield-Goshen W 34-16, Ft. Loramie L 21-63)

OHC 2010 OHSAA Playoffs:
Catholic Central 0-1 (Minster L, 21-44)

OHC 2011 OHSAA Playoffs:
West Liberty-Salem 0-1 (Versailles L 21-48)
Catholic Central 0-1 (Minster L 13-48)

OHC 2012 OHSAA Playoffs:
West Liberty-Salem 1-1 (Dayton Christian W 28-14, Coldwater L 22-41)
Triad 0-1 (Summit Country Day L 27-35)

OHC 2013 OHSAA Playoffs:
Triad 2-1 (Cedarville W 28-7, Lehman Catholic W 14-7, Marion Local L 0-50)
Mechancisburg 3-1 (National Trail W 50-13, Miami East W 31-14, West Liberty-Salem W 34-28 2 OT, Wayne Trace L 10-57)
West Liberty-Salem 2-1 (Williamsburg W 27-20, Summit Country Day W 21-13, Mechanicsburg L 28-34 2 OT)
Cedarville 0-1 (Triad L 7-28)

OHC 2014 OHSAA Playoffs:
Greeneview 1-1 (Mariemont W 35-14, Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy L 14-28)
Mechanicsburg 0-1 (Minster L 41-42 2 OT)
Triad 0-1 (Marion Local L 0-40)
West Liberty-Salem 2-1 (Cincinnati Country Day W 29-7, Tri-County North W 21-14, Minster L 0-35)

OHC 2015 OHSAA Playoffs:
Greeneview 1-1 (Milton-Union W 35-34, Brookville L 7-49)
Mechanicsburg 2-1 (Williamsburg W 48-14, Jefferson W 42-12, Marion Local L 7-9)
West Liberty-Salem 1-1 (Cincinnati Country Day W 21-7, Marion Local L 0-34)

OHC 2016 OHSAA Playoffs:
Greeneview 1-1 (Carlisle W 21-20, Coldwater L 24-27)
Mechanicsburg 2-1 (Miami East W 39-6, Jefferson W 56-20, Marion Local L 15-26)
West Liberty-Salem 0-1 (Marion Local L 7-34)

OHC 2017 OHSAA Playoffs:
Greeneview 0-1 (Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy L 24-47)
Mechanicsburg 0-1 (Spencerville L 0-34)
West Jefferson 2-1 (Bethel-Tate W 48-18, Reading W 35-28, Madison L 7-42)

OHC 2018 OHSAA Playoffs:
Fairbanks 0-1 (Fort Frye L 14-34)
Greeneview 1-1 (Madeira W 31-28, Wheelersburg L 13-35)
Mechanicsburg 0-1 (St. Henry L 7-37)
West Jefferson 0-1 (Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy L 42-49)

OHC 2019 OHSAA Playoffs:
Mechanicsburg 3-1 (Adena W 32-7, Grandview Heights W 48-7, Covington W 42-26, Anna L 6-36)
West Jefferson 3-1 (Summit Country Day W 48-24, Shawnee (Spr) W 62-28, West Liberty-Salem W 34-0, Ironton L 21-49)
West Liberty-Salem 2-1 (Madeira W 21-14, Taft W 14-13, West Jefferson L 0-34)

OHC 2020 OHSAA Playoffs**:
Cedarville 0-0 (vs Mississinawa Valley)
Fairbanks 0-0 (vs Fort Recovery)
Greeneview 0-0 (vs Paint Valley)
Greenon 0-0 (vs winner of Taft/Meadowdale)
Madison Plains 0-0 (vs East Clinton)
Mechanicsburg 0-0 (vs winner of Northeastern/Deer Park)
Northeastern 0-0 (vs Deer Park)
Southeastern 0-0 (vs Lehman Catholic)
Triad 0-0 (vs National Trail)
West Jefferson 0-0 (vs winner of Anna/Miami East)
West Liberty-Salem 0-0 (vs winner of Mariemont/Reading)

*Updated 9/24/20

**In 2020, due to the COVID19 pandemic, all teams were eligible for the playoffs.  Catholic Central was the only OHC school to decline.