2017
1st--BlueDucks Softball (Erie, PA)
2nd--Weaver Production (Franklin, PA)
3rd--Lex Luthers (Westfield, NY)

2016
1st--Hiland Golf Course (Butler, PA)
2nd--Plummer's Tavern (Erie/Ripley)
3rd--Bonar's Mayville Diner (Westfield, NY)

2015
1st--Hunter's Truck Sales (Butler, PA)
2nd--Plummer's Tavern (Erie/Ripley)
3rd--Kallie's Krusade (Jamestown, NY)

2014
1st--Dempsey & Baxter (Erie, PA)
2nd--Big Daddy's Lounge (Dunkirk, NY))
3rd--Mayville Diner (Westifeld, NY)

2013
1st--Big Daddy's Lounge (Dunkirk, NY)
2nd--AJ's Bayview Inn (Erie, PA)
3rd--Larry's Cantina (Westfield, NY)

2012
1st--Dempsey & Baxter (Erie, PA)
2nd--Fralich Chiropractic (Jamestown, NY)
3rd--Larry's Cantina (Westfield, NY)

2011
1st--BlueClaws (Staten Island, NY)
2nd--Nic-L-Inn (Frewsburg, NY)
3rd--Larry's Cantina (Westfield, NY)

2010
1st--Braendel Painting & Services (Erie, PA)
2nd--BlueClaws (Staten Island, NY)
3rd--Betts (Warren, PA)

2009
1st--Bonnell's Collision (Erie, PA)
2nd--Certo Brothers (Westfield, NY)
3rd--Lobster House Hurricanes (Staten Island, NY)

2008
1st--Lobster House Hurricanes (Staten Island, NY)
2nd--Hilltop Beer (Harborcreek, PA)
3rd--Dempsey & Baxter (Erie, PA)

2007
1st--Lobster House Hurricanes (Staten Island, NY)
2nd--Hilltop Beer (Harborcreek, PA)
3rd--

2006
1st--Lobster House Hurricanes (Staten Island, NY)
2nd--Shoeless Joe's (Jamestown, NY)
3rd--Something Different (Brocton, NY)

2005
1st--Bonnell's Collision (Erie, PA)
2nd--Dempsey & Baxter (Erie, PA)
3rd--Folmars Costruction (Harborcreek, PA)

2004
1st--Bonnell's Collision (Erie, PA)
2nd--
3rd--

2003
1st--Bonnell's Collision (Erie, PA)
2nd--
3rd--

2002
1st--Bonnell's Collision (Erie, PA)
2nd--
3rd--

2001
1st--Bonnell's Collision (Erie, PA)
2nd--
3rd--

2000
1st--Bonnell's Collision (Erie, PA)
2nd--Surf Club (Jamestown, NY)
3rd--