Herald-Mail All-Area Selections
Subscribe to our Newsletter
|
2019 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Jaynaz Melendez | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Jalen Goetz | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| RB | Isaiah Knight | Jr. | Saint James | DL | E.J. Ross | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Taj Wagner | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | Ethan Ragno | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Elijah Hill | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Jamon Jones | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Chris Adams | Jr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Jeff Rupp | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Alex Neus | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Ira Roberts | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Will Klein | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Brandon Oyster | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Ben Couling | Sr. | Saint James | LB | D.J. Miller | Soph. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Phil McKevitt | Sr. | Boonsboro | DB | Malaki Pinkney | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Kaelib McElroy | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Tanner Brandimarte | Sr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Devon Napier | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Brady Souders | Sr. | Hancock | |
| WR | Brady Neff | Soph. | Williamsport | DB | Khalil Booker | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| TE | Jacob Moffitt | Jr. | Clear Spring | P | Chase Mapes | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| Utl | Oshane Thorpe | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |||||
| K | Brandon Fink | Sr. | Boonsboro | |||||
| Offensive POY: Ethan Holobinko-RB-Sr.-Boonsboro | Defensive POY: Jamon Jones-LB-Sr.-South Hagerstown | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Jordan Lowery-Clear Spring | ||||||||
| SECOND TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Jared Snow | Jr. | Williamsport | DL | Sahil Bhular | Jr. | Saint James | |
| RB | Zhiear Brown | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Brandon Edwards | Soph. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | A.J. Cook | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Ethan Spears | Jr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Xavier Blair | Jr. | Clear Spring | LB | Jalen Spann | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Micah Myers | Sr. | Clear Spring | LB | Drew Elliott | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Eric Bowens | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Cole Weaver | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| OL | Charles Plummer | Soph. | Hancock | LB | Brian Fink | Sr. | Hancock | |
| OL | Owen Strite | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Beau Meehan | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Ethan Weaver | Sr. | Clear Spring | DB | Kyle Simon-Guerin | Fr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Caleb Everhart | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Jayden Gerringer | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Jacob Zirkle | Jr. | Hancock | DB | Louis Lindsay | Soph. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Tobias Unger | Jr. | Boonsboro | DB | Darby Bryant | Soph. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Justice Allen | Jr. | Hancock | P | Jacob Dugas | Jr. | Saint James | |
| TE | Damien Pulliam | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |||||
| K | Jimmy James | Jr. | Saint James | |||||
|
2018 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Timmy Townsend | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Tayquon Johnson | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Jayswah Sanon | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Christian Teague | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Dustin Fisher | Sr. | Clear Spring | DL | Alexander Springs | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Max Crist | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Rob Purnell | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Greg Gaines | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Michael Teunis | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Jakob Feaster | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | T.J. Quelet | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Steven Schwartz | Sr. | Saint James | LB | Brandon Oyster | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Will Klein | Jr. | North Hagerstown | LB | James Haney | Soph. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Joey Jenkins | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Jeff Rupp | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Chase Osinga | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Andre Myers | Sr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Naeem Watson | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Riley Wolfensberger | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Isaiah Barnhart | Sr. | Boonsboro | DB | Malaki Pinkney | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| TE | Cisco Gonzalez-King | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Ender Hernandez | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| Utl | Ethan Holobinko | Jr. | Boonsboro | Ath | Connor McCuin | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| K | Miles Wyndham | Sr. | Saint James | P | Lincoln Ball | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| Offensive POY: Jayswah Sanon-RB--Sr.-South Hagerstown | Defensive POY: T.J. Quelet-LB-Sr.-Saint James | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Dave Lawrence-South Hagerstown | ||||||||
| SECOND TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Josh DeRocher | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Jakob Connor | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | A.J. Cook | Soph. | North Hagerstown | DL | Daekwon White | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Isaiah Knight | Soph. | Saint James | DL | Ethan Spears | Soph. | Hancock | |
| RB | Bret Artz | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | E.J. Ross | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Dillon Keller | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Dylan Gaver | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Alex Neus | Jr. | Smithsburg | LB | Jamon Jones | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Owen Strite | Jr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Zach Brown | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Chance Marsden | Sr. | Clear Spring | LB | Hayden Norris | Sr. | Hancock | |
| OL | Anthony DeSantos | Jr. | Boonsboro | LB | Jonathan Kamto | Sr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Elijah Keyes | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Eric McDonald | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Larry Barnes | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Cole Weaver | Jr. | Clear Spring | |
| WR | Oshane Thorpe | Jr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Tanner Brandimarte | Jr. | Saint James | |
| TE | Jacob Moffitt | Soph. | Clear Spring | DB | Josh French | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| Ath | Scott Neal | Sr. | North Hagerstown | Ath | Kendyl Faith | Sr. | Hancock | |
| Ath | Reese McLean | Jr. | Hancock | P | Brandon Fink | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| K | Cesar Torres-Lopez | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |||||
|
2017 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Tyler Grochot | Sr. | Saint James | DL | Tayquon Johnson | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Kavon Carter | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | Jakob Connor | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Jalen Anderson | Sr. | Saint James | DL | Jonari Carroll | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Ethan Holobinko | Soph. | Boonsboro | DL | Rob Purnell | Jr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Nick Kidwell | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Evan Wachter | Sr. | Hancock | |
| OL | Ryan Nikirk | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Sam Ewing | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Duncan Burnett | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Brandon Oyster | Soph. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Randy Robinson | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Jonathan Kamto | Jr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Steven Schwartz | Jr. | Saint James | LB | Dylan Shatzer | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| WR | John Metchie | Jr. | Saint James | DB | Noah George | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Nate Moore | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Jake Humble | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Chase Osinga | Jr. | Saint James | DB | Ryan McLaughlin | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| TE | Jordan Jones | Soph. | South Hagerstown | DB | Andre Myers | Jr. | Saint James | |
| Ath | Connor McCuin | Jr. | Smithsburg | P | Seth Hartman | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| Ath | Ethan Souders | Sr. | Hancock | |||||
| K | Brandon Fink | Soph. | Smithsburg | |||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Nick Kidwell-OL-Sr.-Boonsboro | Defensive POY: Tayquon Johnson-DL-Jr.-Williamsport | |||||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Ryan Nikirk-OL-Sr.-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| Coach of the Year: Clayton Anders-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| SECOND TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Jakob Ball | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | Layne Hammond | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Corey Jackson | Sr. | Smithsburg | DL | Shawn King-Pombo | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Jacob Sprecher | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Alexander Springs | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Jayswah Sanon | Jr. | South Hagerstown | DL | E.J. Ross | Soph. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Drew Smith | Sr. | Smithsburg | DL | Christian Teague | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Greg Gaines | Jr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Ben Burgan | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Jacob Feaster | Jr. | Boonsboro | LB | Kai Holman | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Dustin Fisher | Jr. | Clear Spring | LB | T.J. Quelet | Jr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Kurt Hott | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Parker Tribble | Sr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Grant Golden | Sr. | Hancock | DB | Bret Artz | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Chase Molony | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Josh French | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Jeremy Snow | Sr. | Williamsport | DB | Reese McLean | Soph. | Hancock | |
| Ath | Scott Neal | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Cameron Snyder | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| K | Miles Wyndham | Jr. | Saint James | P | Lincoln Ball | Soph. | Williamsport | |
|
2016 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Cole Menas | Sr. | Saint James | DL | Michael Kraeker | Sr. | Saint James | |
| RB | Zach Grams | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Michael Stevens | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Jalen Anderson | Jr. | Saint James | DL | Jonari Carroll | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Kavon Carter | Jr. | Williamsport | DL | Isaiah Warfield | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Nick Kidwell | Jr. | Boonsboro | LB | Reuben Brooks III | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Steven Schwartz | Soph. | Saint James | LB | Zach Rupp | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Jared Tribett | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Cam McClellan | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Duncan Burnett | Jr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Colby Johnson | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Ryan Nikirk | Jr. | Boonsboro | DB | Noah Hamberg | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Jake Arnone | Sr. | Williamsport | DB | Keegan Bowles | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Ravaughn Dillard | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Ryan McLaughlin | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | McCoy Dutrow | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Brooks Keller | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| TE | Mike McCook | Sr. | South Hagerstown | Ath | Lincoln Ikwubuo | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| Utl | John Metchie | Jr. | Saint James | |||||
| K | Bobby Fink | Sr. | Smithsburg | |||||
| Defensive POY: Lincoln Ikwubuo-Ath-Sr.-South Hagerstown | ||||||||
| Offensive POY: Zach Grams-RB--Sr.-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| Coach of the Year: Toby Peer-South Hagerstown | ||||||||
| SECOND TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Timmy Townsend | Soph. | South Hagerstown | DL | Stephen Dunn | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Joe McCoy | Sr. | Clear Spring | DL | Evan Wachter | Jr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Ben Stottlemyer | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Brandon Oyster | Fr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Jayswah Sanon | Soph. | South Hagerstown | DL | Aaron Horton | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Shawn King-Pombo | Jr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Keayon Campbell | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Nick Sattlecker | Soph. | Saint James | LB | Jake Bertrand | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Jakob Feaster | Soph. | Boonsboro | LB | Parker Tribble | Jr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Cam Castle | Sr. | Hancock | LB | Dustin Fisher | Soph. | Clear Spring | |
| OL | John Bennett | Sr. | Williamsport | LB | Taleik McKenzie | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Chase Metz | Jr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Sam Ewing | Soph. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Omar Habwe | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Nate Moore | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Cody Sensenbaugh | Jr. | Clear Spring | DB | Brady Souders | Fr. | Hancock | |
| TE | Kade Knodle | Sr. | Smithsburg | DB | Chase Osinga | Soph. | Saint James | |
| Utl | Ean Mann | Sr. | Hancock | Ath | Connor McCuin | Soph. | Smithsburg | |
| K | Thomas Bacon | Fr. | Saint James | |||||
| 2015 Herald-Mail All-Area |
|
|||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Tyler Rehman | Soph. | Saint James | DL | Dillon Bodenheimer | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Joe McCoy | Jr. | Clear Spring | DL | Sam Haines | Sr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Darian Robinson | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Donta Duncan | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Owen Glass | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Joey Fisher | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| OL | Walter Riley | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Bryce Scott | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Brandon Ngati | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Jared Tribett | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Brad Welsh | Sr. | Hancock | LB | Dre Richmond | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Dylan Alexander | Sr. | Williamsport | LB | Devon Robinson | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Raymond Johns | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Cole Hutzberry | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | John Metchie | Soph. | Saint James | DB | Justin Mitchell | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Lincoln Ikwobuo | Jr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Joey Schwartz | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Cole Menas | Jr. | Saint James | DB | Keegan Bowles | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| TE | Alex Wetzel | Sr. | Boonsboro | Ath | Mike Malphurs | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| Utl | T.J. Peer | Sr. | South Hagerstown | P | Luke Thompson | Sr. | Saint James | |
| K | Bobby Fink | Jr. | Smithsburg | |||||
| Defensive POY: Cole Huntzberry-DB-Sr.-Smithsburg | ||||||||
| Offensive POY: Alex Wetzel-TE-Sr.-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| Coach of the Year: Clayton Anders-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| SECOND TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Devin Griffith | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Michael Kraeker | Jr. | Saint James | |
| RB | Kavon Carter | Soph. | Williamsport | DL | Chance Thomas | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Jake Reed | Sr. | Hancock | DL | Aaron Horton | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Zach Grams | Jr. | Boonsboro | DL | Zach Rupp | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Steven Schwartz | Fr. | Saint James | LB | Cameron McClellan | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Jared Boppe | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Austin Shelton | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Isaiah Warfield | Jr. | Smithsburg | LB | Kamren Winslow | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Nick Kidwell | Soph. | Boonsboro | LB | Tanner Canfield | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Brady Norris | Sr. | Hancock | DB | Ryan McLaughlin | Soph. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Connor Thomas | Sr. | Williamsport | DB | Ben Stottlemyer | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| WR | Scott Neal | Fr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Collin Willhite | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| WR | Marcel Jones | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Darius Bowie | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| TE | James Brooks | Sr. | South Hagerstown | P | Evan Bowman | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| K | Jarrett Rickerds | Jr. | Smithsburg | |||||
| 2014 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Saavon Brown | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | Aaron Dopson | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Darian Robinson | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Sam Haines | Jr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Jesse Wolford | Sr. | Hancock | DL | Dalton Hawkins | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Joe McCoy | Soph. | Clear Spring | DL | Bryce Scott | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | Owen Glass | Jr. | Boonsboro | LB | Sean Tolson | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Travis Kendle | Sr. | Williamsport | LB | Alex Wetzel | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Travis Dodson | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Jeremy Lum | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | George Robinson | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Austin Shelton | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Dakota Pfeiffer | Sr. | Boonsboro | DB | Daniel Moore | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Wes Ambrose | Sr. | Clear Spring | DB | Cole Stotler | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Colby Byers | Sr. | Williamsport | DB | Sinjin Shoop | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Grant Tribble | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Garrett Spinks | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Marcell Jones | Sr. | South Hagerstown | Utl | Noah Teeter | Sr. | Hancock | |
| TE | Ali Robinson | Sr. | Smithsburg | P | Garrett Spinks | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| Ath | T.J. Peer | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |||||
| K | Hunter Martin | Sr. | North Hagerstown | Defensive POY: Austin Shelton-LB-Jr.-South Hagerstown | ||||
| Offensive POY: Saavon Brown-QB-Sr.-Williamsport | ||||||||
| Coach of the Year: Toby Peer-South Hagerstown | ||||||||
| SECOND TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Tyler Rehman | Fr. | Saint James | DL | Brad Welsh | Jr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Jordan Stonebraker | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | Donte Duncan | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | D'Morea James | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Chance Thomas | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Calvin Bembry | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Roy Parker | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Gavin Smoot | Fr. | Saint James | LB | Austin Sigler | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Raymond Johns | Jr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Josiah Johnson | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Ben Lapole | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Tyler George | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Travis Lawson | Sr. | Hancock | LB | Logan Roberts | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Walter Riley | Jr. | Boonsboro | DB | Justin Mitchell | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Brandon Ngati | Jr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Devin Griffith | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Travis Commer | Sr. | Clear Spring | DB | Bakr Banire | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Noah Cisse | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Jake Reed | Jr. | Hancock | |
| WR | Manny Morris | Sr. | Williamsport | Utl | Matt Malphrus | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| TE | James Brooks | Jr. | South Hagerstown | P | Luke Thompson | Jr. | Saint James | |
| Ath | Raughn Carter | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |||||
| K | Nathan Saunders | Sr. | Boonsboro | |||||
| 2013 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
|
FIRST TEAM |
||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Saavon Brown | Jr. | Williamsport | DL | Aaron Dopson | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Isiaha Smith | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Tyler Hollis | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Ethan Foster | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Harrison Layman | Sr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Jordan Stonebraker | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | Sabry Mkamba | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Travis Kendle | Jr. | Williamsport | LB | Josiah Johnson | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Travis Lawson | Jr. | Hancock | LB | Ramal Martinez | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Aaron Miller | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Sean Tolton | Jr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Matt Ritter | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Trevor Walsh | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Garry Robinson | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Isaiah Keyes | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| WR | Colby Byers | Jr. | Williamsport | DB | Collin Schultz | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| WR | Preston Carey | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Sinjin Shoop | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Sherman Harris | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Garrett Spinks | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| Utl | Jesse Wolford | Jr. | Hancock | Utl | Noah Teeter | Jr. | Hancock | |
| K | Brayden Tiner | Sr. | South Hagerstown | P | Eddie Slater | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| Offensive POY: Isiaha Smith-RB-Sr.-South Hagerstown | Defensive POY: Isaiah Keyes-DB-Sr.-North Hagerstown | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Todd Ruppenthal-Hancock | ||||||||
|
2012 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Nick Karlen | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Sarosh Bukhari | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Isiaha Smith | Jr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Josh Miller | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Isaiah Keyes | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Sabre Mkamba | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Justin Jardeleza | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Matt Ritter | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Gerick Allen | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Tre Anderson | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Chris Cook | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Ian McMillen | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Demetrius Edwards | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Oladipo Sadipe | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Marquil Holt | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Andrew Wells | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Trey King | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Ryan Aaron | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| WR | Sherman Harris | Jr. | Saint James | DB | Gabe Fridgen | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| WR | Teon Masser | Jr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Jakerian Jones | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Jesse Zeger | Sr. | Williamsport | DB | Zach Poffenberger | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| Utl | Kyle Hewlett | Sr. | North Hagerstown | Utl | Nate Souders | Sr. | Hancock | |
| K | Mark Grunberg | Jr. | North Hagerstown | P | Ryan Abbott | Jr. | Saint James | |
| Offensive POY: Isiaha Smith-RB-Jr.-South Hagerstown | Defensive POY: Tre Anderson-LB-Sr.-North Hagerstown | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Danny Cunningham-North Hagerstown | ||||||||
|
2011 Herald-Mail AllArea |
||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Adam Mellott | Sr. | Clear Spring | DL | Britton Beard | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Phillip Butler | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Dylan Finney | Sr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Justin Jardeleza | Jr. | Boonsboro | DL | J.R. Lowery | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | J.T. Rice | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Alex Fridley | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Isaiah Smith | Soph. | South Hagerstown | DL | Brandon Starliper | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Malik Barnwell | Jr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Nate Downs | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Dylan Dopson | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Sam Elwood | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| OL | Zach Nalley | Sr. | Williamsport | LB | Robbie Hogue | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Daved Paddack | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Sergio Galvan | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Aaron Rowland | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | C.J. Davis | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Ryan Aaron | Jr. | Clear Spring | DB | Zach Poffenberger | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Tylar Habel | Sr. | Clear Spring | DB | Garrett Wiles | Sr. | Hancock | |
| WR | Josh Hall | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Tyler Wise | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| TE | Aaron Turner | Sr. | Boonsboro | P | J.T. Root | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| Utl | Brandon Hess | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |||||
| K | Mark Grunberg | Soph. | North Hagerstown | |||||
| Offensive POY: Phillip Butler-RB-Jr.-North Hagerstown | Defensive POY: J.R. Lowery-DL-Sr.-Boonsboro | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Clayton Anders-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| 2010 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Hunter Phillips | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DL | Dylan Dopson | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Anthony Winter | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Alex Fridley | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Ben Daniels | Sr. | Smithsburg | DL | J.R. Lowery | Jr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Mike Etzel | Sr. | Clear Spring | DL | Zach Schrieber | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Nick Stubbs | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Ryan Delauter | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Zach Eppard | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Sam Elwood | Jr. | Clear Spring | |
| OL | Jordan Leach | Sr. | Hancock | LB | Michael Franklin | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Brandon Mullins | Sr. | Clear Spring | LB | Trevor Haupt | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Dylan Sharon | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Robbie Hogue | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Mo Townes | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Eric Davis | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| WR | Tylar Habel | Jr. | Clear Spring | DB | Kevin McCormack | Sr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Desmond Meade | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Derek Smith | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Thomas Smith | Jr. | Smithsburg | DB | Eli Souders | Sr. | Hancock | |
| K/P | Tommy Wagner | Sr. | Saint James | Utl | Reggie Russ | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| Offensive POY: Anthony Winter-RB-Sr.-North Hagerstown | Defensive POY: Ryan Delauter-LB-Sr.-Smithsburg | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Craig Bathgate-Clear Spring | ||||||||
| 2009 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| FIRST TEAM | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Casey McKendrick | Sr. | Williamsport | DL | Dana Bender | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | Drew Lowery | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Broc Kline | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Branden McLean | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Joe Perri | Sr. | Saint James | |
| RB | Anthony Winter | Jr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Alex Wolters | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Reggie Russ | Jr. | Williamsport | LB | Nieko Akers | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Dylan Dopson | Soph. | North Hagerstown | LB | Kenny Frey | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Zach Eppard | Jr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Nick Harvey | Sr. | Hancock | |
| OL | Scott Haupt | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Greg Pheabus | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Casey Rowland | Sr. | Smithsburg | DB | Jay Hartley | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Zach Wooten | Fr. | Saint James | DB | Kevin McCormack | Jr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Eli Souders | Jr. | Hancock | DB | Dulaney Williams | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Joey Sutch | Sr. | Williamsport | DB | Dylan Zimmerman | Sr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Avery Wilmore | Soph. | Saint James | Utl | Ken Bosic | Sr. | Clear Spring | |
| K | Jake Gouff | Sr. | Smithsburg | P | Taylor Damuth | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| Offensive POY: Casey McKendrick-QB-Sr.-Williamsport | Defensive POY: Nieko Akers-LB-Sr.-Smithsburg | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Randy Longnecker-Williamsport | ||||||||
| 2008 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Adam Richey | Sr. | Greencastle-PA | DL | Ben Benner | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Casey Cochran | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DL | James Jordan | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Branden McLean | Jr. | Boonsboro | DL | Andre McKenzie | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| RB | Erick Parker | Sr. | Smithsburg | DL | Ken Reid | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| RB | Ryan Rowland | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | LB | Alex Akers | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | John Frick | Sr. | Greencastle-PA | LB | Jordan Fields | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Danny Longerbeam | Sr. | Musselman-WV | LB | Dillon Lechliter | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| OL | Colby Martin | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Greg Pheabus | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Mike Nolet | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | LB | Dylan Spangler | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| OL | Brandon Robinson | Jr. | Waynesboro-PA | DB | Seth Poffenberger | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Jordan Barr | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Jesse Haines | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |
| WR | Cory Shank | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DB | Seth Shindle | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| WR | Anthony Winters | Soph. | North Hagerstown | DB | Dewey McDonald | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| TE | Zech Turner | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | Utl | Mike Russ | Sr. | Saint James | |
| Ult | Josh Conway | Sr. | Smithsburg | |||||
| K/P | Erik Jacobs | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |||||
| Offensive POY: Josh Conway-Ult-Sr.-Smithsburg | Defensive POY: Dylan Spangler-LB-Sr.Waynesboro-PA | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Buddy Orndorff-Smithsburg | ||||||||
|
2007 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Dustin Peters | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DL | Nick Campanelli | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| RB | Justin Donaldson | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Demetrius Myers | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Cody Hess | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DL | Dan Rishell | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | Cody Reed | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DL | Joe Schildt | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| RB | Ryan McLean | Sr. | Boonsboro | DL | Jared Smith | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| OL | James Bishop | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | LB | Alex Akers | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Jesse Lenharr | Sr. | Greencastle-PA | LB | Matt Copenhaver | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| OL | Nathan Minnich | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | LB | Kyle Cunningham | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Jake Stotler | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | LB | Scott Stump | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Steve Whitt | Sr. | Smithsburg | DB | Sam Byrne | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| WR | Kevin Kocsis | Sr. | Smithsburg | DB | Josh Conway | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Mike McMillan | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Dewey McDonald | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| WR | Tyler Mort | Sr. | Mercersburg Acad-PA | DB | Adam Ritchey | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| TE | Chris Selby | Sr. | Boonsboro | Utl | James Jordan | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| Ult | Brandon Hyler | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | |||||
| K | Corey Smith | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Cody Reed-RB-Sr.-Berkeley Springs-WV | Defensive POY: Dan Rishell-DL-Sr.Smithsburg | |||||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Cody Hess-RB-Sr.-Berkeley Springs-WV | ||||||||
| Coaches of the Year: Angelo Luvara-Berkeley Springs-WV | ||||||||
|
2006 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Logan Kelso | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Dan Campbell | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| RB | Josh Twyman | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DL | Bryce Hobbs | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Chad Brown | Sr. | Smithsburg | DL | Trey Hobbs | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Cody Hess | Jr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DL | Vince Van Orden | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Jimmy Sutch | Sr. | Saint James | LB | Matt Copenhaver | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| OL | Tappah Dinnall | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Jonathan Hash | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| OL | Tyler Dopson | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | LB | Daniel Kershner | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| OL | Rusty Hughes | Sr. | James Buchanan-PA | LB | Cadyn Robinson | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Clayton Rohrer | Sr. | Smithsburg | DB | Alex Barone | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| OL | Jacob Waugh | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DB | Sam Byrne | Jr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| WR | Jarell Hasan | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Allen Kees | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| WR | Michael Lopez | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | DB | Xavier Peters | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| WR | Ryan Trochimowicz | Sr. | Musselman-WV | P | Chris Reid | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| Ult | Kyle Kane | Sr. | Boonsboro | |||||
| K | Corey Smith | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |||||
| Offensive POY: Josh Twyman-RB-Sr.-Martinsburg-WV | Defensive POY: Dan Campbell-DL-Sr.-Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Clayton Anders-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| 2005 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Patrick Burns | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | DL | Andrew Crown | Jr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Mike McKenzie | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | DL | Josh Edgin | Sr. | Mercersburg Aca-PA | |
| RB | Ryland Newman | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | DL | Bryce Hobbs | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Tyler Perry | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | DL | Chad Jones | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| RB | Eric Zwilsky | Sr. | Brunswick | LB | Bobby Humphries | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Dan Campbell | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Robert Fields | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Charles Curry | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | LB | Tyler Moser | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Tyler Hockman | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | LB | Rusty Moser | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| OL | Matt Rhoderick | Sr. | Boonsboro | DB | Kevin Berrigan | Soph. | MD School for the Deaf | |
| OL | Bryan Rouzee | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | John Freels | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| WR | Eddie Dorsey | Jr. | Saint James | DB | Kyle Leonard | Jr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| WR | Ryan Morris | Jr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DB | Zach Shoemaker | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| WR | Scott Ritter | Sr. | St. John's Prospect Hall | P | Thomas Teyssier | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| Ult | Randal Smedley | Jr. | St. John's Prospect Hall | Ult | Josh Brown | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| K | Adam Wiestling | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |||||
| Offensive POY: Mike McKenzie-RB-Sr.-Waynesboro-PA | Defensive POY: Bobby Humphries-LB-Sr.-Thomas Johnson | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Clayton Anders-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| 2004 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Keith Ricca | Sr. | St. John's Prospect Hall | DL | Trey Coble | Sr. | James Buchanan-PA | |
| QB | Nate Sowers | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DL | Jeremiah Seeley | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Bruce Dorsey | Sr. | Frederick | DL | Dink Snowden | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Will Grantham | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | DL | T.J. Taylor | Sr. | Frederick | |
| RB | Justin Thompson | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Matt Feiser | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | Eric Zwilsky | Jr. | Brunswick | LB | Bobby Humphries | Jr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Jessie Highling | Sr. | Frederick | LB | A.J. Riner | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| OL | Nick Kelsey | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | LB | Dean Staley | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Andrew Presnell | Sr. | Middletown | DB | Kenny Clark | Sr. | Hancock | |
| OL | Eric Scott | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DB | Clint Castellar | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| OL | Mitch Wolters | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Dustin Mitchell | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| WR | Quielan Gantt | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | D.J. Porter | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| WR | Erick Burkholder | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | P | Billy Gross | Sr. | Frederick | |
| WR | Max Morris | Sr. | St. John's Prospect Hall | Ult | Tony Belt | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| K | Brent Toms | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |||||
| Offensive POY: Nate Sowers-QB-Sr.-Martinsburg | Defensive POY: Matt Feiser-LB-Sr.-Smithsburg | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Richard Mills-Jefferson | ||||||||
| 2003 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Nate Sowers | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | DL | Brandon Fields | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Shawn Beachley | Sr. | Middletown | DL | Jayson Hoelscher | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| RB | Bryan Slater | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | John Kline | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Antoine Crawford | Sr. | Walkersville | DL | Ryan West | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| RB | Matt Mason | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | LB | Matt Feiser | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Jason Doherty | Sr. | Middletown | LB | Derrick Keith | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Dan Dreisonstok | Sr. | Walkersville | LB | Chris Nichols | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Ken Rendel | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Jordan Sterner | Sr. | Hancock | |
| OL | Jeremiah Seeley | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | T.J. Bowser | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | J.R. Whitsell | Sr. | Catoctin | DB | Jason Johnson | Sr. | Catoctin | |
| WR | Brandon Barrett | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | David Miner | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Max Morris | Jr. | St. John's Prospect Hall | DB | Tyler Spurlock | Sr. | Brunswick | |
| WR | Matt Rockwell | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | P | Zach Tanner | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| K | Steve Emswiller | Sr. | Musselman-WV | Ult | Dustin Mowen | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| Co-Offensive POY: Nate Sowers-QB-Jr.-Martinsburg | Defensive POY: Derrick Keith-LB-Sr.-North Hagerstown | |||||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Brandon Barrett-WR-Sr.-Martinsburg | ||||||||
| Coach of the Year: Danny Cunningham-North Hagerstown | ||||||||
| 2002 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Nate Sowers | Soph. | Martinsburg-WV | DL | Ryan Cutsail | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Josh Keeney | Sr. | Middletown | DL | Clayton Swisher | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Jamar Garner | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | DL | Chris Malamet | Sr. | Frederick | |
| RB | Mo Rodriguez | Sr. | Saint James | DL | Jason Nalewak | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| RB | Dustin Sier | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Ryan Harshman | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Bryan DeMoss | Sr. | Middletown | LB | Nick Houpt | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Ryan Madison | Sr. | Musselman-WV | LB | Mike Leichitski | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Sam Miller | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | LB | Ryan Nesbitt | Sr. | Catoctin | |
| OL | Davis Moore | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Adam Ellison | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | David Schanuel | Sr. | Walkersville | DB | David Miner | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | Brandon Barrett | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Jamie Moore | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | |
| WR | Brandon Monroe | Sr. | St. John's Prospect Hall | DB | Justin Unger | Jr. | Hancock | |
| WR | Matt Rockwell | Jr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | P | David Green | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| Ult | Brandon Dykes | Sr. | Brunswick | Ult | Nathan Himes | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| K | Brent Toms | Soph. | North Hagerstown | |||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Josh Keeney-RB-Sr.-Middletown | Co-Defensive POY: Ryan Cutsail-DL-Sr.-Middletown | |||||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Brandon Barrett-WR-Jr.-Martinsburg | Co-Defensive POY: Clayton Swisher-DL-South Hagerstown | |||||||
| Coach of the Year: Greg Kellick-South Hagerstown | ||||||||
|
2001 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Joey Yurish | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DL | Chris Dillon | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Jerrod Brown | Sr. | Frederick | DL | A.J. Johnson | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| RB | Josh Keeney | Jr. | Middletown | DL | Jeb Keller | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| RB | Steve Weatherholtz | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DL | Davis Moore | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Dustin Sier | Jr. | Smithsburg | LB | Mike Daye | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Kyle Godwin | Sr. | Middletown | LB | Mike Dietrich | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Dave King | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Shannon Suttle | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Clint Rice | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Aaron Warner | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Steve Roach | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Nick Maas | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| OL | Steve Weaver | Sr. | Boonsboro | DB | Scott Rice | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| WR | Brandon Barrett | Soph. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Wayne Toms | Sr. | Brunswick | |
| WR | Matt Rockwell | Soph. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DB | Troy Ward | Sr. | Frederick | |
| WR | Jermar Togans | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | P | Chris Anderson | Sr. | Middletown | |
| TE | Brooks Moser | Sr. | Middletown | Ult | Chip Brown | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| Ult | Jason Neil | Sr. | James Buchanan-PA | |||||
| K | Andy Shutts | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |||||
| Offensive POY: Joey Yurish-QB-Sr.-Martinsburg-WV | Defensive POY: Aaron Warner-LB-Sr.-Martinsburg-WV | |||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Angelo Luvara-Berkeley Springs-WV | ||||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Clayton Anders-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| 2000 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Kyle Fields | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DL | Sean Moore | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| RB | D.J. Costello | Sr. | Middletown | DL | Ryan McDonald | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Chris Dobrzanski | Sr. | Hancock | DL | Akil Patterson | Sr. | Frederick | |
| RB | Mike Jemison | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DL | Nikolai Payne | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Damon McDowell | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | DL | Steve Roach | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Jason Abbott | Sr. | Walkersville | LB | Ryan Fay | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | |
| OL | Walter Drill | Sr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Ryan Fritz | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Nick Paskowsky | Jr. | Frederick | LB | Tuck Hess | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| OL | Clint Rice | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Frankie McAllister | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| OL | Matt Strine | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Chip Brown | Jr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| WR | Brandon Barrett | Fr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Devin Hosby | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| WR | Mike Flanagan | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DB | Nick Maas | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| WR | David Steele | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | DB | Joe Windle | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| Ult | Robert Staley | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | P | Andy Shutts | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |
| K | Justin Nowell | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |||||
| Offensive POY: Mike Jemison-RB-Sr.-Greencastle-Antrim-PA | Defensive POY: Sean Moore-DL-Sr.-Hedgesville-WV | |||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Glenn Cross-North Hagerstown | ||||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Greg Kellick-South Hagerstown | ||||||||
| 1999 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Todd Mosby | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DL | Jason Cutsail | Sr. | Middletown | |
| QB | Kyle Fields | Jr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DL | Thomas DeMoss | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Jason Chambers | Jr. | Musselman-WV | DL | Josh Lashley | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Darrell Clopper | Sr. | Smithsburg | DL | Nikolai Payne | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Mike Jemison | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DL | Tony Wilson | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| RB | Damon McDowell | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | LB | Chris Dankmeyer | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | George Burns | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | LB | Tyler Hart | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| OL | Jamie Dillon | Sr. | Middletown | LB | John Tsikerdanos | Sr. | Frederick | |
| OL | Pat Jansen | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Sam Williams | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Dwayne Robinson | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DB | Keylan Brown | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Dewey Weddle | Jr. | Walkersville | DB | Mike Flanagan | Jr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | |
| WR | Willie McLane | Sr. | Brunswick | DB | Mike Hixon | Sr. | Hancock | |
| WR | Lance Williams | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | DB | Lane Strobel | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| WR | Peter Yos | Sr. | Musselman-WV | Ult | Kevin Dingus | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| TE | David Royer | Sr. | Hancock | P | Jon Henson | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| K | Bubb Rader | Jr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | |||||
| Offensive POY: Todd Mosby-QB-Sr.-Mussleman-WV | Defensive POY: Chris Dankmeyer-LB-Sr.-Boonsboro | |||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: David Walker-Martinsburg-WV | ||||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Tim Ambrose-Middletown | ||||||||
|
1998 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Chad Wiley | Sr. | Catoctin | DL | Paul Arbogast | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |
| QB | Kyle Fields | Soph. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DL | Brett Bartles | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| RB | Sam Hess | Sr. | Hancock | DL | Kelly McNamee | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Aaron Edwards | Jr. | Chambersburg-PA | DL | Nathan Rushing | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Mike Jemison | Soph. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DL | Saeed Samad | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| RB | Trevor Shade | Sr. | Musselman-WV | LB | Mike Corbin | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| OL | Danny Tinsmen | Sr. | Musselman-WV | LB | Kevin Hurlbrink | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Tyler Hart | Jr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Britt Sherman | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Matt Cordell | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Trent Strumbaugh | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| OL | George Coyle | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Josh Thumma | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Chris Monroe | Sr. | Middletown | DB | Jamere Burnett | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| WR | Chris Aker | Sr. | Saint James | DB | Scott Folmar | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| WR | Matt Kranchick | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DB | Rodney Hanes | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| WR | Mike Irvine | Sr. | Catoctin | DB | Walter Medina | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| Ult | Todd Mosby | Jr. | Musselman-WV | Ult | Kevin Dingus | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |
| K | Chad Brock | Soph. | Musselman-WV | P | Bill Windle | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| Co-Offensive POY: Sam Hess-RB-Sr.-Hancock | Co-Defensive POY: Nathan Rushing-DL-Sr.-Middletown | |||||||
| Co-Offensive POY: Mike Jemison-RB-Soph.-Greencastle-PA | Co-Defensive POY: Scott Folmar-DB-Jr.-Chambersburg-PA | |||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Mark Mitchell-Brunswick | ||||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Denny Price-Musselman-WV | ||||||||
| 1997 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Hunter Cross | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Lorenzo Davis | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| QB | Ricky Roberts | Jr. | Thomas Johnson | DL | Sam Hess | Jr. | Hancock | |
| RB | Mike Cleveland | Sr. | Linganore | DL | Josh Kline | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Matt McJilton | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DL | Chad Oberholzer | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| RB | Walter Medina | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DL | Ryan Suter | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Jason Priecko | Jr. | South Hagerstown | LB | Leroy Ambush | Jr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Doug Hocker | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Joey Bradshaw | Jr. | Linganore | |
| OL | Ryan Meehlieb | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | LB | James Corbett | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Jason Morris | Sr. | Walkersville | LB | Byron Reed | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| OL | Nathan Rushing | Jr. | Middletown | LB | Justin Wiggs | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| OL | Adam Troutman | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | DB | Scott Folmar | Jr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| WR | Mike Irvine | Jr. | Catoctin | DB | Kirk Friedman | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| WR | Larry Scott | Jr. | Saint James | DB | J.D. Kirby | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| WR | Alex West | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DB | Matt Price | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| Ult | Ken Robey | Jr. | Middletown | Ult | Mike Briscoe | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| K | Jason Powell | Sr. | Linganore | P | Nathan Springer | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| Big School Offensive POY: Matt McJilton-RB-Sr.-Musselman-WV | Big School Defensive POY: Byron Reed-LB-Sr.-Hedgesville-WV | |||||||
| Small School Offensive POY: Hunter Cross-QB-Sr.-North Hagerstown | Small School Offensive POY: James Corbett-LB-Sr.-Middletown | |||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Chuck Tinninis-Greencastle-Antrim-PA | ||||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Doug Williams-Catoctin | ||||||||
| 1996 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Chris Benson | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DL | Jamie Fisher | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| QB | Matt Main | Sr. | Middletown | DL | Dave Rock | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| RB | Mike Cleveland | Jr. | Linganore | DL | Evan Routzahn | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Vince Collette | Sr. | Walkersville | DL | Paul Shull | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| RB | Denero Marriott | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DL | Josh Wolf | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| RB | Mike Sanders | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | LB | Jason Fritz | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Adam Dunham | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | LB | Blake Harper | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Yarnell Gilbert | Sr. | Walkersville | LB | Jimi Massey | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Fred Joye | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | LB | Byron Reed | Jr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| OL | Dave Lowe | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Juwuane Sandridge | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Eric Meske | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DB | Pat Currier | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| WR | Mike Bush | Jr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DB | Randall Jones | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| WR | Jason Dirting | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Braheem Powell | Sr. | Scotland-PA | |
| WR | J.R. Rush | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DB | Matt Price | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |
| K | Sean McCarthy | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | P | Drew Folmar | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| Big School POY: Randall Jones-QB/DB-Sr.-Thomas Johnson | ||||||||
| Small School POY: Chris Benson-QB-Sr.-Mercersburg Academy-PA | ||||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Hal Grau-Walkersville | ||||||||
| Co-Coach of the Year: Eric Michael-Williamsport | ||||||||
| 1995 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Chris Benson | Jr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DL | Tim Everhart | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| QB | Matt Main | Jr. | Middletown | DL | Mike Hull | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Frank Aliveto | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | DL | Fred Joye | Jr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| RB | Chris Jones | Sr. | Scotland-PA | DL | Andrew Potter | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Cory Russ | Sr. | Saint James | DL | Sheldon Tucker | Jr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| RB | Jeff Siedor | Sr. | Linganore | LB | Jason Dawson | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Jon Tobery | Sr. | Middletown | LB | Nathan Dunham | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| OL | David Chlebowski | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Andy Hershey | Sr. | James Buchanan-PA | |
| OL | Andy Dills | Sr. | Linganore | LB | Ben Morrow | Sr. | Linganore | |
| OL | Chris Scheuch | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | LB | Dan Woodlin | Jr. | Scotland-PA | |
| OL | Josh Wolf | Jr. | Walkersville | DB | Kirk Grantham | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| WR | Kam Christensen | Sr. | Middletown | DB | Randall Jones | Jr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| WR | J.R. Rush | Jr. | Musselman-WV | DB | Mel Keyes | Sr. | Saint James | |
| WR | Elmer Sewell | Sr. | Smithsburg | DB | Denero Marriott | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |
| K | Justin Brown | Sr. | Linganore | P | Joe Cronise | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| Big School POY: Frank Aliveto-RB-Sr.-Hedgesville-WV | ||||||||
| Small School POY: Cory Russ-RB-Sr.-Saint James | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Tim Ambrose-Middletown | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Andy Schroer-Mecersburg Academy-PA | ||||||||
|
1994 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Mark Gurson | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DL | Anthony Cleary | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| RB | Frank Aliveto | Jr. | Hedgesville-WV | DL | Mike Hull | Jr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | L.J. Jackson | Sr. | Frederick | DL | Chris Scheuch | Jr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| RB | Bill Reuter | Sr. | Smithsburg | DL | Will Sowers | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| RB | Cory Russ | Jr. | Saint James | LB | Eric Folmar | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| RB | Tytus Taylor | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Mike Gusman | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Jeremy Barkdoll | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Andy Hershey | Sr. | James Buchanan-PA | |
| OL | Bear Henson | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | LB | Mark Janus | Jr. | Williamsport | |
| OL | Adam Hoffman | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | LB | Jon Walters | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Mike Keller | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | DB | Chris Abbott | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| OL | Jason Phillips | Sr. | Middletown | LB | Eric Bender | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| E | Kirk Grantham | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Tim Carter | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| E | Nathan Quay | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | DB | Nathan Foltz | Sr. | Middletown | |
| E | Elmer Sewell | Jr. | Smithsburg | DB | Mel Keyes | Jr. | Saint James | |
| K | Justin Brown | Jr. | Linganore | P | Jim Koontz | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| Big School POY: Anthony Cleary-Sr.-Chambersburg-PA | ||||||||
| Small School POY: Jon Walters-Sr.-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Carroll Reid-Smithsburg | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Ben Wright-Thomas Johnson | ||||||||
|
1993 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Colby Cloude | Jr. | Thomas Johnson | DL | Anthony Cleary | Jr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| RB | Jermaine Ballard | Sr. | Walkersville | DL | Kevin Fortney | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| RB | Bill Helm | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | DL | Bill Kidd | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Joe Seetog | Sr. | Linganore | DL | Andy Rockwell | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Jay Steadham | Sr. | Saint James | DL | Vinnie Tardino | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| RB | Tytus Taylor | Jr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Doug Bigelow | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Ryan Hines | Sr. | Linganore | LB | Shawn Edelen | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Zach Hilliard | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | LB | Matt Koons | Jr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| OL | Gabe Lesher | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | LB | Mike Long | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Robert Myers | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | LB | Mike Pitts | Sr. | Saint James | |
| OL | Derek Smith | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | LB | Jason Smith | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| E | Ricky Henderson | Sr. | Brunswick | DB | Chris Ashton | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| E | Elmer Sewell | Soph. | Smithsburg | DB | Eric Bender | Soph. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| E | Jamie Stotler | Sr. | Berkeley Springs-WV | DB | JarrodDonaldson | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| K | John Osmann | Sr. | Middletown | P | Brinton Byers | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| Big School POY: Mike Long-Sr.-Thomas Johnson | ||||||||
| Small School POY: Doug Bigelow-Sr.-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Clayton Anders-Boonsboro | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Ed Snyder-James Buchanan-PA | ||||||||
| 1992 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Dana Schrodel | Sr. | Walkersville | DL | Sean Haga | Sr. | Brunswick | |
| RB | E.J. Fuller | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Chet Mitchell | Sr. | Linganore | |
| RB | Mike Rouzer | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | DL | Kevin Sowers | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| RB | John Seymour | Sr. | Linganore | DL | Jim Battle | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| RB | Chris Triggs | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DL | Josh Hough | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| OL | Kevin Engle | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | DL | Chris Moore | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| OL | Andy Perdas | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Denny Fortney | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| OL | Bret Thompson | Sr. | Linganore | LB | Chris Kretsinger | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Norm Hann | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | LB | Mike Long | Jr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| OL | Ricky Zittle | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | LB | Dennis Weeks | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| OL | Joe Dattoli | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | DB | Colby Bachtell | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| E | Jason Allder | Sr. | Walkersville | DB | Michael Jackson | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| E | Tony Allen | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | DB | Ted Murphy | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| E | Ricky Henderson | Jr. | Brunswick | DB | Dom Novack | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| K | John Osmann | Jr. | Middletown | P | Andy Horner | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| Big School POY: John Seymour-RB-Sr.-Linganore | ||||||||
| Small School POY: Andy Horner-Andy Horner-RB/LB-Musselman-WV | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Denny Price-Musselman-WV | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Darwin Seiler-Waynesboro-PA | ||||||||
|
1991 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Danny Cunningham | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DL | Mike Pilch | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Colby Bachtell | Jr. | Smithsburg | DL | Chet Mitchell | Jr. | Linganore | |
| RB | Mike Rouzer | Jr. | Waynesboro-PA | DL | Brett McIntire | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| RB | John Seymour | Jr. | Linganore | DL | Bill Krumpe | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | Scott Frye | Sr. | Brunswick | DL | Pete Nicklas | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| OL | Donald Bishop | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DL | Greg Stup | Sr. | Frederick | |
| OL | Matt Cooper | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | LB | Denny Fortney | Jr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| OL | Chris Kretsinger | Jr. | Smithsburg | LB | Richard Queen | Sr. | Middletown | |
| OL | Matt Morrison | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | LB | Telly Reel | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| OL | Jerry Putt | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Tobby Williams | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| OL | Joe McDowell | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DB | Larry Hite | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| E | Matt Arthur | Sr. | Walkersville | DB | Brad Friedman | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| E | Ted Murphy | Jr. | Hedgesville-WV | DB | Jason Miller | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | |
| E | Tony Ware | Sr. | North Hagerstown | DB | Danny Reese | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| K | Kevin Reed | Sr. | Middletown | P | Andy Horner | Jr. | Musselman-WV | |
| Big School POY: John Seymour-RB-Jr.-Linganore | ||||||||
| Small School POY: Tobby Williams-RB/LB-Smithsburg | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Carroll Reid-Smithsburg | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Ron Renner-Hedgesville-WV | ||||||||
|
1990 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Mike Scott | Sr. | Smithsburg | DE | Renell Jones | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| RB | Richard Snowden | Jr. | Frederick | DE | Eric Coles | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Travis Blubaugh | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DE | Matt Good | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | James Frisby | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DT | Buddy Hesen | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| RB | Don Houser | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | DT | Steve Draper | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| RB | Kenny Carr | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | NG | Granison Johnson | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| T | Pete Adkins | Sr. | Brunswick | LB | David Clark | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| T | Duke Holliway | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Tobby Williams | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| G | James Brill | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | LB | Rob Unger | Sr. | Saint James | |
| G | Bobbie Shank | Sr. | Williamsport | LB | Darren Bumbaugh | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| G | Steve Petry | Sr. | Musselman-WV | LB | Chad Putnam | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | |
| C | Pat Darlington | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DB | Matt Robinson | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| E | David McKinney | Sr. | Hedgesville-WV | DB | Kevin Griffith | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| E | Bootsie Washington | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | DB | Tom Shelton | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| E | Brian Dugan | Sr. | Catoctin | DB | Jason Johnson | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| K | Scott Nowell | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | P | Eric Rodnick | Sr. | Middletown | |
| Big School POY: Kenny Carr-RB-Sr.-Jefferson-WV | ||||||||
| Small School POY: Rob Unger-RB/LB-Sr.-Saint James | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Glenn Cross-North Hagerstown | ||||||||
| Co-Coaches of the Year: Ron Gray-Martinsburg-WV | ||||||||
| 1989 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Marsalis Basey | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | DE | Ronnie Carter | Sr. | Williamsport | |
| RB | Shawn Kimple | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | DE | David Clark | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| RB | Jamey Peters | Sr. | Smithsburg | DT | Richie Baker | Sr. | Linganore | |
| RB | Lionell Royer | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DT | Ron Webb | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| RB | Chad Wiestling | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DT | Mark Widder | Sr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | |
| RB | Kenny Carr | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | NG | Pete Adkins | Sr. | Brunswick | |
| T | Jamie Stottlemyer | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Clay Grove | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| T | Brad Hykes | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Jim Updegraff | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| G | Terrance Williams | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Brian Sine | Sr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| G | Tommy Nussear | Sr. | Smithsburg | LB | Josh Eighenbrode | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| G | Fred Householder | Sr. | Williamsport | DB | David Shelton | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| C | Jarad Handleman | Sr. | Linganore | DB | Curtis Thomas | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| E | Kurt Zobrist | Sr. | Middletown | DB | Gary Carter | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| E | Todd Stoner | Jr. | James Buchanan-PA | DB | Chip Bachtell | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| K | Chris Lewis | Sr. | Musselman-WV | P | Mike Ellis | Sr. | Linganore | |
| 1988 Herald-Mail All-Area | ||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | J.P. Filchock | Sr. | Walkersville | DE | Derek Ruffin | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | Jesse Ketterman | Sr. | Catoctin | DE | Chris Orndorff | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| RB | Darrell Hunter | Sr. | Musselman-WV | DE | Ben Hotchkiss | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Reece Brown | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | DT | Barrett Todd | Sr. | Middletown | |
| RB | Chad Wiestling | Jr. | Greencastle-Antrim-PA | DT | Dan Massey | Sr. | Saint James | |
| T | Rich Duncan | Sr. | North Hagerstown | NG | Eric Bryant | Sr. | Saint James | |
| T | Jon Hixon | Sr. | Walkersville | LB | Rob Bolton | Sr. | Middletown | |
| T | Brian High | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | LB | Bobby Wilt | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | |
| G | Ben Tutt | Sr. | Mercersburg Acd-PA | LB | Jim Updegraff | Jr. | Smithsburg | |
| G | Jim Nugent | Sr. | Walkersville | LB | Darren Eichelberger | Sr. | Frederick | |
| C | Ben Breeze | Sr. | Middletown | DB | Mark Burger | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| E | Mike West | Sr. | Smithsburg | DB | Marsalis Basey | Jr. | Martinsburg-WV | |
| E | Sean Patterson | Sr. | Walkersville | DB | Lyle Shipley | Sr. | Musselman-WV | |
| E | Robbie Bowins | Sr. | Thomas Johnson | DB | Keith Potter | Sr. | Boonsboro | |
| K | Chris Lewis | Jr. | Musselman-WV | P | Chuck Brandenburg | Sr. | Middletown | |
|
1987 Herald-Mail All-Area |
||||||||
| Consensus | ||||||||
| OFFENSE | DEFENSE | |||||||
| QB | Troy Wilt | Sr. | Jefferson-WV | DE | Mitchell Branch | Jr. | North Hagerstown | |
| RB | Andre Henry | Sr. | Frederick | DE | Steve Fitzgerald | Sr. | Linganore | |
| RB | Dwayne Freeman | Sr. | South Hagerstown | DT | Tim Cole | Sr. | Linganore | |
| RB | Donald Staggers | Sr. | Walkersville | DT | Ron Johnikin | Sr. | Brunswick | |
| RB | Ron Mesaros | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | LB | Brad Huntzberry | Sr. | Smithsburg | |
| T | Randy Hart | Sr. | North Hagerstown | LB | Bobby Page | Sr. | Walkersville | |
| T | Jim Nichols | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Shawn Reynolds | Sr. | North Hagerstown | |
| G | Gerald Reeder | Sr. | Boonsboro | LB | Travis Mathews | Sr. | Linganore | |
| G | Chris Finneyfrock | Sr. | Catoctin | DB | Aaron Dudley | Sr. | South Hagerstown | |
| G | Chris Smith | Sr. | Walkersville | DB | Dusty Stockslager | Sr. | Chambersburg-PA | |
| C | Jeff Crampton | Sr. | Boonsboro | DB | Tom Hoffman | Sr. | Waynesboro-PA | |
| E | James Jett | Jr. | Jefferson-WV | P | Chuck Brandenburg | Jr. | Middletown | |
| E | Ivan Ward | Sr. | Smithsburg | |||||
| K | Chris Lewis | Soph. | Musselman-WV | |||||
