ALGOMA Penguins, vs CASCO Athletics

 Manager, Tom Stodola

1933 - Casco, 7-5 - Algoma, 5-3

1934 - Casco, 6-4 - Algoma, 6-5

Manager, Bill Albrecht

1935 - Casco, 8-1 - Algoma, 6-1

1936 - 1953 - No games were played these years.

Manager, Zeb Shaw

1954 - Algoma, 8-1 - Algoma, 19-3

1955 - Algoma, 9-3 - Algoma, 30-0

1956 - Algoma, 8-2 - Algoma, 10-6

1957 - Algoma, 15-0 - Algoma, 3-0 - Algoma, 14-3

1958 - 1959 - No games were played these years.

Manager, Gaylord Mauer

1960 - Algoma, 2-1 (10in) - Algoma, 6-5 - Casco, 1-0

Manager, Jerry DeMeuse

1961 - Algoma, 22-7

1962 - Algoma, 8-0 - Algoma, 10-3 - Algoma, 6-3

Manager, Gaylord Mauer

1963 - Algoma, 9-0 - Algoma, 11-0 - Algoma, 18-4 - Algoma, 13-0

1964 - 1975 - No games were played these years.

Manager, Steve Schinderle

1976 - Algoma, 3-2

1977 - Algoma, 17-2 - Algoma, 5-3 - Algoma, 16-2

1978 - Casco, 5-3 - Algoma, 4-2 - Algoma, 11-8 - Algoma, 4-2

Manager, Terry Qualman

1979 - Algoma, 6-1 - Casco, 9-6 - Algoma, 11-4

Manager, Bud Sibilsky

1980 - Algoma, 4-3 - Casco, 12-10 - Algoma, 9-4

1981 - Algoma, 16-7 - Algoma, 1-0 - Algoma, 11-9

Manager, Todd Kirchman

1982 - Casco, 10-9 - Algoma, 5-3 - Casco, 9-7

1983 - Algoma, 15-1 - Algoma, 18-4 - Algoma, 3-0

1984 - No games were played this year.

1985 - Casco, 5-3 - Casco, 9-8

1986 - Casco, 9-1 - Casco, 12-4

Manager, Pete Swoboda

1987 - Casco, 12-2 - Casco, 16-3 -  Algoma, 4-1 (10in)

1988 - Algoma, 12-3 - Casco, 14-6 - Algoma, 9-5

1989 - No games were played this year.

1990 - Casco, 9-7 - Casco, 13-11 - Casco, 9-6

1991 - Casco, 7-3 - Casco, 9-4 - Casco, 5-4 (10in)

1992 - Casco, 18-17 - Casco, 16-2 - Casco, 17-7

Manager, Corie Zimmerman

1993 - Casco, 11-1 - Casco, 6-1 - Casco, 3-1

1994 - Casco, 16-5 - Casco, 9-3 - Algoma, 6-5 (11in) - Casco, 15-11

1995 - Algoma, 12-7 - Casco, 12-6 - Algoma, 9-4

Manager, Barry "Bearcat" Schoening

1996 - Casco, 9-4 - Casco, 15-4 - Casco, 18-4

1997 - Casco, 9-8 - Algoma, 10-2 - Casco, 13-6

1998 - Casco, 4-3 - Casco, 5-4 - Casco,9-4

Manager, Jeff DeMeuse

1999 - Casco, 10-0 - Casco, 10-8

2000 - Casco, 10-9 - Casco, 10-1

2001 - Algoma, 8-7 - Casco, 12-3 - [SBL, Semi-Finals] - Casco, 12-6 - Casco, 10-1

2002 - Algoma, 14-13 (12in) - Casco, 12-5 - Algoma, 9-5

Manager, Mike "Cabbage" Lukes

2003 - Casco, 7-6 - Algoma, 9-3 - Casco, 17-5 - [SBL, Semi-Finals] - Casco, 13-9 - Algoma, 16-7 - Casco, 13-8

2004 - Algoma, 11-10 - Algoma, 10-9 - Casco, 8-3 - Algoma, 22-12

Managers, Derek Ray & Ben Romdenne

2005 - Algoma, 17-3 - Casco, 6-0 - Casco, W-L

Manager, Terry Qualman

2006 - Casco, 9-1 - Algoma, 4-3 - Algoma, 5-1

2007 - Casco, 1-0 - Casco, 1-0 - Casco, 6-3

2008 - Casco, 8-6 - Casco, 6-2 - Algoma, 3-2

2009 - Casco, 2-1 - Algoma, 4-2 - Casco, 2-1

2010 - Casco, 5-3 - Algoma, 8-3 - Algoma, 3-0

2011 - Algoma, 5-3 - Algoma, 9-5 - Algoma, 12-0

Manager, Todd Kirchman

2012 - Casco, 10-3 - Algoma, 6-5 - Casco, 16-4

Manager, Chad LaLuzerne

2013 - Algoma, 7-6 (10in) - Casco, 2-1

Game Totals:  134 Games,  Algoma, Wins-67 - Casco, Wins-67